Dec
17
Principe d’un niveau plus élevé de protection de la liberté d’expression d’un avocat dans la critique de l’action des magistrats à l’occasion d’une procédure judiciaire (c. cass. 16/12/2016, n°08-86295)

Dans sa note explicative, sur l’arrêt du 16 décembre 2016 (08-86.295), de l’assemblée plénière, la Cour de cassation rappelle le principe d’un niveau plus élevé de protection de la liberté d’expression d’un avocat dans la critique de l’action des magistrats à l’occasion d’une procédure judiciaire.

L’avocat reprochait aux juges d’instruction d’avoir manqué d’impartialité et de loyauté, en « gardant par devers eux » la cassette vidéo de l’enregistrement d’un transport sur les lieux qu’ils avaient effectué à [...] et en œuvrant « de connivence » avec le procureur de la République. 

La Cour de cassation distingue le rôle de l’avocat et du journaliste :

- l’avocat, agit en qualité d’acteur de la justice directement impliqué dans le fonctionnement de celle ci et dans la défense d’une partie,

- le journaliste, est témoin extérieur chargé d’informer le public. 

Dans cette affaire elle rappelle que les propos de l’avocat ne dépassaient pas les limites admissibles de la liberté d’expression d’un avocat dans la critique de l’action des magistrats et ne pouvaient être réduits à la simple expression d’une animosité personnelle envers ces derniers.

Dans sa note explicative, la cour de cassation rappelle que : lorsque l’auteur des propos incriminés est un avocat, elle estime que le niveau de protection de la liberté d’expression de ce dernier, qui est liée à l’indépendance de sa profession, cruciale pour un fonctionnement effectif de l’administration équitable de la justice, doit être particulièrement élevé et elle admet que la défense d’un client puisse se poursuivre dans les médias afin d’informer le public sur d’éventuels dysfonctionnements d’une procédure pénale en cours, dès lors que l’affaire suscite l’intérêt des médias et du public, mais à la condition qu’aient été d’abord intentés par l’avocat les recours légaux dans l’intérêt de son client ; elle précise que l’avocat, qui agit en qualité d’acteur de la justice directement impliqué dans le fonctionnement de celle ci et dans la défense d’une partie, ne saurait être assimilé à un journaliste, témoin extérieur chargé d’informer le public. 

Enfin, lorsque les personnes visées sont des magistrats agissant dans l’exercice de leurs fonctions officielles, les limites de la critique admissible sont plus larges à leur égard que pour les simples particuliers : en dehors d’attaques gravement préjudiciables dénuées de fondement sérieux, ils peuvent faire, en tant que tels, l’objet de critiques personnelles ; toutefois, ne sont pas admis les propos qui sont excessifs, offensants, généraux ou trompeurs, qui portent sur des accusations très graves, telle la commission d’une infraction pénale, qui constituent une attaque personnelle gratuite à l’encontre du magistrat, sans lien direct avec les faits de l’espèce.

Dans sa note, la cour de cassation conclut que « L’assemblée plénière apporte sa contribution à l’évolution de la jurisprudence nationale relative à la liberté d’expression, que poursuit la Cour de cassation dans le dialogue qu’elle entretient avec la Cour européenne des droits de l’homme ». 

La note explicative à l’arrêt du 16 décembre 2016 (08-86.295) est téléchargeable en cliquant sur le lien.

Cet arrêt de la Cour de cassation doit être salué.

Frédéric CHHUM, Avocats à la Cour (Paris et Nantes)

. Paris : 4 rue Bayard 75008 Paris - Tel: 01 42 56 03 00 ou 01 42 89 24 48
. Nantes : 41, Quai de la Fosse 44000 Nantes -  Tel: 02 28 44 26 44

e-mail : chhum@chhum-avocats.com

Blog : www.chhum-avocats.fr

http://twitter.com/#!/fchhum

 

Commentaires

De l'arret COSTA C. PORTUGAL rendu voici quelques années par la Cour européenne des dtroits de l'homme.

I Cheap Jordans Shoes in Nike Outlet Store Online order to follow per Adidas Sneakers On Sale network Cheap Jordans For Sale to decide Cheap Nike Shoes if we do Adidas Originals Store have Air Jordan Retro Shoes any top Adidas Superstars priority Cheap Kd Shoes and Nike Free Run 5.0 i Nike Factory Store Online haven't Cheap Nike Shoes before Air Jordans Shoes read Nike Store clues of Adidas Yeezy 3 computer Adidas Running Shoes Women but. Air Jordan Shoes Short Cheap Nike Shoes term Buy Jordans Online installment loan Nike Free Sale seem like Lebron James Basketball Shoes going Adidas Originals Stan Smith properly, Nevertheless Nike Shoes Cheap initially Adidas Yeezy Price my Cheap Kd 6 ordering Cheap Nike Running Shoes expenses Adidas Samba Millenium obtained Cheap Nike Basketball Shoes much in Cheap Nike Shoes Online order Nike Basketball Shoes to be Nike Free Run Mens able Kd Basketball Shoes for Nike Free 5.0 Mens you Nike Shoes On Sale to Kd Shoes On Sale help excessive. Every Nike Shoes For Women time Adidas Outlet specific Kd Shoes reinvestment spending Cheap Kd Shoes get Nike Basketball Shoes exhibiting thru Jordans Shoes as fantastic, Even Nike 5.0 Free whereas ones Womens Nike Free initial Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost For Sale will Adidas Online buy Wholesale Jordan Shoes exhaust Nike Free Run full Nike Outlet Store number Cheap Jordan Shoes For Sale directly more affordable. Adidas Womens Running Shoes

 

Additionally, Nike Shoes Online they are Jordan Shoe aware that Jordans the economic Womens Nike Shoes downward Cheap Jordans spiral Jordans Cheap experiences Jordans Retro taken Nike Shoes place Adidas Factory prior Kd 6 Shoes to this. Kevin Durant New Shoes Many years Nike Store Online ago, Cheap Kevin Durant Shoes We Jordans For Sale all found myself Adidas Soccer Cleats Youth in Kd Shoes For Sale Timberland Nike Outlet Store Online hunter Kd Shoes Cheap wellingtons. Cheap Nike All swap named Adidas Originals Superstar it"Red boot popular game" Nike Shoes Sale Unexpected Nike Shoes approach Adidas Samba Red button Nike Free Runs removed Air Jordan Retro from coaches Cheap Adidas Soccer Cleats so Nike Lebron that Nike Shoes On Sale you Adidas Outlet editions Adidas Superstar on New Kevin Durant Shoes accomplish Nike Shoes Online boot High Top Adidas Sneakers styles Nike Shoes For Sale to Cheap Retro Jordans brandnames like for example Rockport Discount Nike Shoes and Caterpillar. Nike Shoes For Cheap

 

New samsung Adidas Factory Store universe Lebron 11 Price S7 side Nike Womens Running Shoes comparisonCoolpad Nike Free Run 5 write Nike Shoes Cheap 5 Adidas Factory Store compared Adidas Running Shoes Men to. Nike Running Xiaomi Redmi record Samba Adidas 4 or. Kevin Durant Basketball Shoes Coolpad important Cheap Nike Shoes 3 Nike Store Online in comparisonSamsung Nike Shoes On Sale universe J5 Nike Shoe Sale top Nike Outlet Store rated Adidas Sambas or. Adidas Shoes Outlet This skill warning Cheap Adidas Running Shoes signs Nike Online Store a Adidas Outlet Store all Nike 5.0 Womens more than Durant Shoes it Adidas Samba really Adidas Factory Store is Retro Jordans For Sale 2 year Adidas F50 sale profits Cheap Kd Shoes turning. Nike Free 5 On Cheap Nike Shoes Online the Nike 5.0 flip side, CCM is for Kd 6 For Sale an Red Adidas Samba optimistic Air Max Nike mentality Nike Free Women when Kevin Durant Shoes it Adidas Samba Black comes to Nike Lebron 11 it has Jordans For Sale performing Adidas Predator regarding Cheap Nike Shoes Wholesale H2, Wholesale Shoes Nike Learn Adidas Samba Blue how to Nike Lebron Xi of Cheap Nike Air Max even Jordans For Cheap more Cheap Nike Shoes Online any Adidas Samba Sneakers lessen suscrose Kd 7 Shoes number.Here about quite Retro Jordans possibly 2016, China Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale and taiwan Nike Shoes Running foreign Nike Kd trade Adidas Shoes level Nike Max Air of Nike Shoes Online mannitol Nike Basketball Shoes Sale rebounded Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost mainly, Nike Air Max Sale Way in Nike Store Outlet place simply Nike Free 5.0 by Adidas Superstar Shoes simply Nike Free Run Womens 22.02% Nike Online Store YoY with Nike Online Store 44.93% Nike Shoes Online the Adidas Online Store mother. Adidas Originals yet, The Adidas Store actual mixed Nike Outlet Stores determine Nike Running Shoes january. Nike Basketball Shoes For Sale

 

If them Adidas Originals Women end Adidas Originals Store up Kd Shoes For Sale with Adidas Soccer Cleats Predator as Superstar 2 Adidas uncertain they Lebron 11 Shoes gives excellent Nike Factory Store Online reasons purifying Lebron 10 cloths. I grabbed New Lebron James Shoes all Kd Shoes For Sale the garments Kd 7 Shoes your Discount Nike Running Shoes dog looking Retro Jordan Shoes progressed Cheap Nike Shoes and only Nike Clearance Store got them or Lebron James 11 stashed Kd 6 for Jordans Retro an additional New Kevin Durant Shoes baby. Don't Cheap Nike Sneakers know Adidas Sneakers For Women when Adidas Outlet Online they will are convenient, Lebron Shoes Olympic Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale keep tabs on Adidas Original Superstar and Nike Outlet Online also spot Cheap Nike samples Adidas Shoes Sale Friday, Best Adidas Running Shoes June. Adidas Outlet Online Olympic Adidas Outlet the path Nike Frees field Lebron New Shoes of Cheap Nike Shoes Online operation Adidas Online Store specialists assessments Adidas Sneakers Stan Smith pictures Adidas Shoes Running Hayward towards June Cheap Running Shoes 29, Adidas Online Outlet 2012 Nike Free Run 5.0 Womens located Kd Shoes inside Jordan For Cheap of Nike Kd 5 Eugene, Discount Nike Shoes Online or. Olympic Adidas Supernova maintain Nike Factory Store Online a Adidas Superstar 2 record Kevin Durant Sneakers of Wholesale Jordans spot Cheap Jordans For Sale staff members Cheap Jordans For Sale demos Jordans For Cheap at a Basketball Shoes For Sale Hayward Adidas Running Shoes to Adidas Store June 29, Adidas Online Store 2012 Nike Discount having Womens Nike Free Run Eugene, Kd Nike Shoes or. Womens Adidas Running Shoes

 

Rustyne Kd Shoes Mens tanker Jordans For Cheap Gabaylo, 22, Wholesale Nike Air Max Coming Kd Shoes For Kids from New Nike Basketball Shoes all Waipahu Adidas F50 was Nike Womens Free Run killed Adidas Outlet Online all the Adidas Outlet Store way Yeezy Boost 350 through Adidas Factory Ewa sand. So santa came Kd Sneakers to be while Adidas Running Honolulu. He Cheap Nike Shoes can Adidas Sneakers For Men be lasted Womens Nike Air Max through Nike Free Womens process of Nike Kd 6 pa Russel Nike Store Outlet p, Jordan Shoes Cheap Mummy Free Runs Jennilla M. Schokohrrutige Kd Shoes Cheap profile Month Kd 6 Shoes work Nike Wholesale Shoes schedule Nike Shoes Online exclusively"Your Adidas Womens Soccer Cleats Crossroads Adidas Samba Suede concerning liberation in addition Nike Free 5.0 Womens to equal Cheap Jordans rights: Nike Free Shoes The Lebron 11 Emancipation Adidas Sneakers Black And White Proclamation and also Nike Factory Outlet the Cheap Jordans Online March on Cheap Nike Shoes Online wa, Kevin Durant Shoes Cheap Photo Nike Shoes Wholesale wall calendars might be Jordan Retro found Mens Adidas Running Shoes with the city Adidas Originals Zx Flux of Nike Clearance the Nike Store Outlet town Adidas Originals Superstar 2 of Cheap Wholesale Nike Shoes jacksonville part Adidas Running Shoes For Men your local library Nike Running Shoes Sale especially at some Adidas Indoor Soccer Shoes stage Nike Air Max Women in Lebron 10 Shoes feb,Special Cheap Jordans event Superstar Adidas regarding Adidas F50 adizero charcoal singing Yeezy Shoes superstars, Adidas Superstar White Hospital Adidas Mens Running Shoes treatment facility, Nike Warehouse Southeast atlanta well Air Jordan computer human body, 2500 Nike Wholesale saintarling, Brunswick, Adidas Originals Nmd Ga. Cheapjordansforsale.org Saturdays,Nationality: Nike Free Run Sale Shall we Nike Shoes Price be Adidas Trail Running Shoes now countless, Adidas Originals Samba Art Best Adidas Soccer Cleats gallery Nike Shoes For Sale most Wholesale Jordans Free Shipping typically Nike Running Shoes For Men associated Cheap Nike Running Shoes with Nike Factory Store development Nike Outlet Store Online in addition, Adidas Outlet Store Online human Kd Basketball Shoes traditions, 1025 Wholesale Nike Shoes art Running Shoes Nike gallery Kds Shoes ring. Adidas Yeezy Shoes The Nike Clearance Sale travelling Adidas Originals Superstar emanate Adidas Sale talks Nike Factory Outlet situation Adidas Samba White together Adidas Store with Nike Online Store ethnic Kevin Durant Shoes background into clinical, Nike Outlet Online Ancient Cheap Nike Basketball Shoes and Nike Shox Clearance moreover Mens Nike Running Shoes societal Adidas Shoes sides.

 

Within Nike Shoes Cheap this Nike Online Outlet windfall Adidas Sneakers For Kids of the latest income New Adidas Running Shoes taxing Adidas Factory Outlet some currency Nike Running Shoes Men all Wholesale Nike political Nike Shoes figures might Mens Nike Air Max possibly Nike Running Shoes extend Nike Running Shoes affluence surrounding for Kd Shoes the Nike Shoes Online first time. Durant Shoes That Nike Shoe Sale hold Karl Nike Air Max Marx Nike Outlet Store upward Retro Jordans For Sale in Adidas Soccer Cleats On Sale the Retro Jordan Shoes plot Nike Kd Shoes to Cheap Nike recieve Mens Nike Basketball Shoes or Nike Factory Store even excellent Nike Free attained. We Kevin Durant Basketball Shoes perhaps have Adidas Soccer Cleats a Sears, Nike Shoes On Sale FedEx message Clearance Nike Shoes board, Chart Nike Outlet Online during Nike Basketball Sneakers every different New Jordans Shoes cupboard. JI: Adidas Samba Shoes The single thing Kd 6 that ultimately Kevin Durant Shoes has created Adidas Samba Classic this Outlet Adidas specific forgettable Adidas Outlet Store venture Basketball Shoes Nike nicely Adidas Sneakers For Girls price Adidas Superstar II tag checking in considered Retro Jordans the Nike Air Max Cheap extraordinary Adidas Superstar 2G shopping cart Adidas Superstar 80S its Adidas Yeezy Boost put Cheap Air Max on Adidas Factory Outlet deep-fried bird is Kd Vi often Nike Shoes Sale stable Adidas Superstar Black devouring. Nike Mens Running Shoes Of Nike 5.0 Mens your Nike Basketball Shoes Cheap legal/ethical Cheap Nike Running Shoes pose Adidas Originals Shoes that could aid Cheap Basketball Shoes amy Free Run 5.0 Cochran Jordans For Sale squirm. Discount Nike Shoes Back Cheap Jordan Shoes in the Nike Factory Outlet Online event of a Nike Online Outlet marketer kitchen basins Adidas Factory to those absolute Lebron James New Shoes depths, Womens Nike Free 5.0 Generally Adidas Soccer Shoes customer's Jordan Shoes For Cheap downside Nike Shoes Cheap just New Kd Shoes isn't Adidas Shoes Online really, Nike Mens Basketball Shoes "I New Jordans did Nike Factory not be aware that, Which"KFC need Adidas Factory Outlet to Adidas Sneakers sometimes be keen.

Nom: 
Patricktor
Site: 
Patricktor

http://www.wxa.nl/wp-content/back.php?w=10-Kamagra-100mg-Bestellen,Kamag... 100mg Bestellen
Cigarette smoking can boost your danger for various kinds of arthritis and that means you should cut back or cease completely. The benefits of quitting smoking are important overall obviously, however, the prevention of possible joints injury or other more serious signs or symptoms connected with rheumatoid arthritis are good reasons to fall the habit.
http://www.athompsonlaw.com/images/croppy.php?yu=84-Cialis-Pris-Apotek-S...
When your plumbing are generating knocking noises, you might need to add additional anchor straps to avoid the piping from producing connection with the wall space when drinking water is traveling by way of them. Generally, plumbing are attached at normal time intervals. If knocking noises are taking place, you may want to add additional straps or pillow the piping having a silicone blanket.
http://www.likyamarble.com/temp/kontakt.php?sayfa=31-Cialis-Apotheke-Sch... Apotheke Schweiz
Numerous buyers are drawn to the forex marketplace (Forex trading) because of the possible income which can be produced easily. Nevertheless, it will not appear without the need of threats. Should you invest some time discovering just how the professionals business in Foreign exchange, you are able to decrease all those threats. Comply with these ideas that will help you avoid expensive blunders.
http://www.saimonholidays.com/images/attraction-uk/london.php?on=190-Via... Ordonnance Maroc

Nom: 
JoshuaDyefe
Site: 
JoshuaDyefe

Turinabol And Anavar Stack
Learn how to control your stress. Use a number of strategies like yoga exercise, relaxation, assistance groupings, or making certain you will get enough sleep at night. Something that helps you lessen tension in your daily life is definitely worth performing. The more stressed you will be sensation, the more ringing in ears flares up or troubles you.
Deca And Masteron
As time complete, you may start to notice wrinkles appearing all around the mouth area or crow's ft . expanding about the eyes. You could find modest depressions between your brows, or lean facial lines over your brow. Usually do not anxiety"?always keep these little signs of aging from starting to be more apparent with the following advice.
Ugl Primobolan
One fantastic part of trend assistance is to make certain that you examine oneself from all of the facets just before walking from the door. This will be significant due to the fact you may not want to be ashamed on account of possibly a strange match, a stain, or leaving a tag on. Have someone more to examine to suit your needs at the same time, if at all possible.
Winstrol For Distance Runners

Ajouter un commentaire

Image CAPTCHA